As Florida employment
lawyers, we know that the great majority of employment discrimination cases
involve claims of intentional discrimination asserted by individual workers.
Although large in number, these cases do not usually attract much publicity or attention.
They do not involve large classes of employees and they do not challenge
affirmative action plans. They are, instead, cases where an individual
plaintiff, claims that an adverse personnel decision was based on a prohibited
characteristic, of which race, sex, ethnicity or others is the paradigm.
The most heavily
litigated issue by Florida employment lawyers is the definition of intentional
discrimination, an issue worked out mainly through allocation of the burden of
proof. The opinions on burden of proof have succeeded in formulating a
consistent set of doctrinal rules. They have been less successful in achieving
the broader goals of assuring the consistent resolution of employment
discrimination claims, controlling the allocation of issues between judge and
jury, and expediting the overall process of settlement and litigation. The
tension between the actual effects of doctrinal rules and what they were
designed to accomplish, here as elsewhere in the law, results in continuing
litigation and continuing attempts to improve upon existing law by employment
attorneys.
Statutory Definitions of
Discrimination are the subject of much dispute among Florida employment
lawyers. This is most attributed to the fact that the law does not contain any
definition of intentional discrimination as a technical term of art. Neither do
any of the other statutes modeled on Title VII. In this respect, employment
attorneys rely on the aspects of the statutory law of employment discrimination
that follows constitutional law. Leaving the exact nature of what is prohibited
without any precise definition. In fact, the phrase "intentional
discrimination" is at least partly redundant. All discrimination is
intentional in some sense because it requires noticing or acting on some kind
of distinction.
As Florida employment
lawyers, we do feel that you should know that practices, including any form of
discrimination or segregation affecting an individual's employment
"because of such individual's race, color, religion, sex, or national
origin” is both illegal and actionable.